Reconsidering the “New Normal”: Socioeconomic and ecological diversity in post-Katrina New Orleans


The phrase "new normal" is often used to refer to the complex and multi-faceted outcomes of post-disaster recovery and reconstruction processes. Generally, the volatility and chaos occurring immediately after a trauma are followed by a relative stabilization, usually at levels and configurations different from the pre-trauma "normal." This NSF and USFS-funded (ULTRA-Ex program) exploratory research project is investigating the impact of trauma on urban ecological and social systems using post-Katrina New Orleans as a study area. Ecological and social measures are being used to track and characterize the transition from trauma to stabilization. Data is being analyzed to measure patterns of ecological and social diversity. "Ecological diversity refers to species richness and dominance, community structure and composition, succession stage, land cover, and other measures. "Social diversity" tracks human population differentiation in terms of class (median household income), race, ethnicity, age, education, nativity, gender, renter/homeowner status, and other metrics. Achieving this objective involves GIS-based spatial analysis of pre- and post-trauma landscape and social metrics derived from satellite imagery and the 2000 and 2010 federal census. This citywide study will be supplemented with three fine-grained studies in the neighborhoods of the Lower Ninth Ward, Hollygrove, and Pontchartrain Park. Qualitative data collected in these neighborhoods is intended to provide insight into the relationships between trauma and ecological and social diversity, and identify variation in the timing, pace, and trajectory of neighborhood recovery. A second objective of this study is the organization and coordination of a network of scholars and practitioners to exchange experience and knowledge and thereby increase understanding of the complex interactions and connections among trauma, human actions, and urban ecosystems.

This project is intended to yield empirical, theoretical, and practical contributions to understanding the interactions of humans and natural ecosystems. Empirically, this project is providing extensive data and analyses on social diversity and post-trauma stabilization at detailed spatial scales. Organizationally, this project is helping to establish a broad-based, interdisciplinary research program that will identify the human and natural system drivers of post-trauma urban ecosystem changes and strategies for responding to these changes.  By leveraging the research and education resources of three major universities (Tulane University, the University of New Orleans, and Xavier University), this project is fostering unique collaborations between ecologists and social scientists and will broaden participation of underrepresented groups in generating new knowledge about human-natural system interactions.

Ecology of Urbanizing Deltas

Related links

  1. Website of Kevin Gotham, Tulane University: http://www.tulane.edu/~kgotham/gotham.html

  2. Syracuse ULTRA program: http://www.esf.edu/cue/ULTRA/

  3. Portland-Vancouver ULTRA program: http://www.fsl.orst.edu/eco-p/ultra/

  4. Triangle ULTRA program: http://triangleultra.wikispaces.com/

  5. Miami Dade ULTRA program: http://miamiultra.fiu.edu/

  6. Fresno-Clovis ULTRA program: http://urban-faces.org/

  7. Boston ULTRA program: http://www.bu.edu/ultra-ex/

  8. San Juan ULTRA program: http://sanjuanultra.org/

  9. NYTimes article on ULTRA-Ex symposium: http://green.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/08/11/as-ecosystems-cities-yield-some-surprises/?_r=0

  10. NYTimes Magazine article on post-Katrina urban ecology: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/25/magazine/the-lower-ninth-ward-new-orleans.html?pagewanted=all

Diversity & Disease in post-Katrina New Orleans


Though it is widely held that environmental and societal well-being are intricately linked, little is known about relationships and interactions among ecological and human communities. Urban landscapes that have experienced a catastrophic event (i.e., trauma) can be highly tractable systems for studying potential parallels and feedbacks. With acute trauma resulting in an initial state change, the (re)assembly of proximate or coincident urban ecological and human communities can be a coupled dynamic, where outcomes (e.g., diversity) are contingent on responses to common drivers or interactions arising from management interventions. For better or worse, catastrophic flooding of New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina in August 2005 has resulted in a natural laboratory for investigating coupled (re)assembly. This NSF-funded project (CNH program) is being carried out to determine the extent to which ecological and socioeconomic diversity exhibit parallel responses to Katrina-related flooding. Research also is being done to examine how interventions executed as public health measures shape relationships and interactions between ecological and socioeconomic diversity. This involves GIS analyses of landscape heterogeneity and socioeconomic variation before and after Hurricane Katrina, as well as plot-based inventories of post-Katrina plant communities according to flooding and socioeconomic stratification. The ecology and demography of Norway rats (Rattus norvegicus), a habitat-dependent primary reservoir of zoonotic pathogens, is being examined to understand human health outcomes of flooding. This involves a trapping-based census; population genetic analysis of abundance and dispersal; as well as histological analysis of pathogen prevalence. Mail surveys and in-person interviews of households proximate to plant inventory and trapping sites, and of households in four neighborhoods factorial selected according to income and ethnicity, are being conducted to determine how perceptions of risk compare to physical measures of exposure risk across the city. Information gained from these studies will be united into a spatially-explicit predictive model of Norway rat demography to assess ecological and human-health outcomes of alternative control scenarios reflecting habitat suitability, movement, and risk perceptions.


Trauma can have enduring consequences on environments and societies. Understanding the interplay between ecological and human communities will better prepare societies to anticipate and manage trauma inflicted by catastrophic events. All elements of this project- from data collection to education initiatives- will not only help catalyze conceptual unification of disparate fields of research on the composition, assembly, and structure of communities, they will generate discoveries needed to foster and inform societal action at a time when unprecedented resources are being invested to rebuild New Orleans. By involving community partners, cross-university academic and public outreach programs will afford opportunities to promote awareness of trauma, diversity, and public health across stakeholder and underrepresented groups in the city. With urbanization placing an increasingly greater proportion of the global population at risk of experiencing a catastrophic event, and with the traumas experienced by New Orleans continuing to cast a long shadow on contemporary events, it is also expected that the research, training and educational outcomes of this project will resonate with people around the world.


  1. Gotham, K., Blum, M.J., Campanella, R. 2014. Toward a new normal: Trauma, diversity, and the New Orleans Long-Term Research Area Exploratory Project. Cities and the Environment  7: 4.


  1. Ernstson H, S van der Leeuw, CL Redman, DJ Meffert, G Davis, C Alfsen, and T Elmqvist. 2010. Urban Transitions: On Urban Resilience and Human-Dominated Ecosystems. AMBIO


  1. Gotham, K., Campanella, R., Lewis, J., Gafford, F., Nance, E., Mallikharjuna R.A. 2011. Reconsidering the New Normal: Vulnerability and Resilience in Post-Katrina New Orleans. Global Horizons: The Journal of Global Policy and Resilience 4: 121.


  1. Gotham, K., Campanella, R. 2010. Toward a research agenda on transformative resilience: Challenges and opportunities for post-trauma urban ecosystems. Critical Planning v17


  1. Gotham, K., Campanella, R. 2011. Coupled vulnerability and resilience: The dynamics of cross-scale interactions in post-Katrina New Orleans. Ecology and Society 16: 12.


  1. Gotham, K. 2012. "Disaster, Inc.: Privatization and Post-Katrina Rebuilding in New Orleans. Perspectives on Politics

  1. Mendenhall, I.H., Bahl, J., Blum, M.J., Wesson, D.M. 2012. Genetic structure of Culex erraticus populations in the Americas. Journal of Medical Entomology 49: 522-534.


  1. Rael, R., Peterson, A., Ghersi-Chavez, B., Blum, M.J. Disturbance, reassembly and disease risk in socioecological systems.  (in revision)


Related links

  1. NSF Dynamics of Coupled Natural Human Systems Program: http://www.nsf.gov/funding/pgm_summ.jsp?pims_id=13681

  2. NSF Ecology and Evolution of Infectious Diseases program: http://www.nsf.gov/funding/pgm_summ.jsp?pims_id=5269

  3. Ecoepidemiology of leptosporosis in the urban slums of Brazil: http://projectreporter.nih.gov/project_info_description.cfm?aid=8452345&icde=13885034

  4. Yale program in eco-epidemiology: http://www.yale.edu/yibs/research/CEE.html

  5. Ecohealth Alliance: http://www.ecohealthalliance.org/

  6. NYTimes article on the ecology of disease: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/15/sunday-review/the-ecology-of-disease.html?_r=1&ref=jimrobbins

  7. Laboratory of Dr. Jason Munshi-South: http://nycevolution.org/

  8. http://www.yourwildlife.org/2013/05/genomics-of-the-ratopolis/

  9. New Orleans Mosquito, Termite and Rodent Control Board: http://www.nola.gov/mosquito/


Water sustainability and climate in the Lower Mississippi River Delta


Climate driven sea-level rise and an intensified hydrological cycle are threatening water resources in the New Orleans metropolitan area and surrounding Mississippi River Delta. Variable river discharge and sea level rise can promote cycles of degradation by increasing flooding potential and salinity in regional waterways. Reversing the onset or progression of degradation will involve managing freshwater supply (including reintroduction of freshwater and sediment into wetlands), enabling the sequestration of nutrients that can potentially restore highly valued habitat, and removal of toxins that challenge human and ecosystem health. Science and engineering alone will not be sufficient to implement effective management plans. Well-defined policy and legal frameworks will be essential for progressive management interventions. Similarly, engaging local stakeholders to enhance awareness of concerns about water sustainability will be necessary to ensure ecological and community resiliency under future climate conditions.

The purposes of this NSF-funded (WSC program) incubation project are to develop a strong organizational framework, to enhance existing research capacity and infrastructure, and to obtain critical baseline data that will set the stage for the development of a comprehensive understanding of water quality and management issues in the Mississippi River Delta region. A demonstration project is being carried out to illustrate integrative coastal water management in the study area. This project focuses on management of water quality in an urban-influenced wetland hydrologic system. The research team is also assessing government jurisdiction and property rights related to data on historical and current water and environmental conditions. This work is intended to provide a baseline understanding of water quality issues at the study site. The study also uses focus groups consisting of local stakeholders to collect data on the historical context and perceptions of environmental change and to inform the development of tenable policy solutions. These efforts involve a working group composed of experts and community partners. The goals of the working group are to enhance water resources data management to promote institutional management and community awareness in the proposed study area, and to identify key challenges and priority research areas that are most likely to offer practical solutions for water sustainability in vulnerable coastal environments.

  1. Chatfield, M.W.H., Dalbom, C.J., Blum, M.J. Megarestorations: Too big to fail, too big to succeed? (in preparation)

Related links

  1. NSF Water Sustainability and Climate Program: http://www.nsf.gov/funding/pgm_summ.jsp?pims_id=503452

  2. South Florida WSC program: http://sfwsc.fiu.edu/

  3. U Wisconsin-Madison WSC program: http://wsc.limnology.wisc.edu/

  4. Sunbelt WSC program: http://www.waterforthesunbelt.org/

  5. Michigan WSC program: http://www.miseagrant.umich.edu/nsf/

  6. L9th Ward Center for Sustainable Engagement and Development: http://blog.sustainthenine.org/wetlands/

  7. EDF profiles in restoration: http://blogs.edf.org/restorationandresilience/2010/03/04/profiles-in-restoration-the-central-wetlands-unit-part-i/

  8. LDNR Bayou Bienvenue restoration project plan: http://dnr.louisiana.gov/assets/docs/coastal/interagencyaff/nonpoint/wetlands/1C.%20nos&wb.bayoubienvenue.pdf