Editions and Printings: Matching Editions
Part I. G.
(See also Part II.E, on editing records for multivolume titles)
Prefer a record with the same edition statement, place, publisher, date(s), and series as
your piece(s), if available. However, if there is no matching record with all these
elements, check the piece(s) carefully, for example, seeking evidence whether one
publisher took on the multivolume title from another publisher (same edition) or whether
more than one edition has been or is being published concurrently (different editions).
One caveat: There may be a question whether the item should be treated as a volume of a
monographic set, using a single, multivolume bibliographic record, or as part of an
analysed series on a separate bibliographic record. Be sure to check both possibilities
when searching; if you have any questions, consult with your trainer or with the Library
Associate.
-
- If the edition statement, place of publication, publisher, or date of a
volume of a multivolume title does not match the information in the
record, but there is no indication that a volume with the same number
was used in cataloguing that record, the record may still be accepted as a
match if everything else that can be verified matches.
(Cf. Part II.E.1-4, on editing editor statement, edition statement,
and imprint in multivolume records.)
- E.g. The 260 $a is Berlin; 505 field includes only v. 1.
- You are cataloguing v. 2, published in Vienna. There is no record
with a Vienna imprint,
- and no evidence of a v. 2 published in Berlin.
- You may accept this Berlin record.
- (Cf. Part II.E.3, section on editing place of publication
in multivolume records.)
- E.g. 250 $a 1st ed.
- 260 $a Ashby de la Zouch : $b Scatterbrained Press
- 505 1 $a v. 2. Regional finds, 1450-1650
- You are cataloguing v. 3, Regional finds, 1650-1800, which
includes a "Second edition"
- statement. The place and publisher are
the same. There is no record for the 2nd ed. and,
- in the piece, no
evidence of a second edition of any other volumes.
- You may accept the 1st ed. record.
- (Cf. Part II.E.2, section on editing edition statement
in multivolume records.)
- E.g. 260 $a London : $b W. Heinemann, $c 1943-
- 505 1 includes only v. 1-3.
- You are cataloguing v. 5, published: Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard
University Press, 1986.
- There is no Harvard University Press
record.
- You may accept this Heinemann record.
- (Cf. Part II.E.3, section on editing publishers
in multivolume records.)
- E.g. 260 $a [Paris] : $b Gallimard, $c 1980-
- 505 1 $a v. 1
- You are cataloguing v. 3, published: Paris : B. Grasset, 1982. On
the page facing the t.p.,
- there is a reference to v. 1-2, published by
B. Grasset 1979-1981.
- The Gallimard record should not be used. If there is no record for
the B. Grasset edition,
- an original record should be input.
Note that the chronological order of the publications of volumes in a
multivolume set may not correspond to the order of the volume numbers.
For example, a set might be published in the following order: v. 2 (1973);
v. 4-6 (1977); v. 7 (1980); v. 3 (1984); v. 1 and v. 8 (1986). Thus, the
date of a volume is not, by itself, a factor in matching.
(Cf. Part II.E.4, section on editing dates
in multivolume records.)
- E.g. 260 $a Manchester : $b Manchester University Press, $c 1986-
- 505 1 $a v. 2. Complete essays
- You are cataloguing v. 1, Complete poems, published by
Manchester University Press in 1990.
- You may accept this record.
- If the edition statement or date of a volume of a multivolume title is later
than the information in the record, and a volume with the same number
was in fact used in cataloguing that record, the record can still be accepted
as a match only if there is evidence that individual, isolated volumes have
been revised separately and that a new edition of the entire multivolume set
is not being published.
- E.g. T.p.: Hermann Pfeffernuss / Sämtliche Werke / Band IX / Der
Lebkuchen / (Verbesserte
- Ausgabe) / 1990
- This piece is a revised edition specifically of Bd. 9; the preface
explains that it was updated
- after new sources on this little-known
masterpiece became available.
- There is a record for the original edition of the Sämtliche Werke
[Collected works], which
- includes an unrevised Bd. 9. There is no
record of a "verbesserte Ausgabe" of the collected
- works.
- The record for the original edition may be used.
- (Cf. Part II.E.2, section on editing edition statement
in multivolume records.)
- If you encounter any other type of edition or date situation for
multivolume titles, you should consult with your trainer or with the
Library Associate.
Go to top of this document
-
(Cf. Part II.E.5, on editing physical description
in multivolume records.)
- If the record shows a multivolume title as closed with a volume earlier
than the volume designation in the piece, the record may still be a match.
However, it is safest to check with your trainer or with the Library
Associate before proceeding further.
- A single-volume record may also be expanded to a multivolume record, if
the situation warrants. Again, though, it is safest to check with your
trainer or with the Library Associate before proceeding further.
- E.g. 245 10 $a Coping with the absurd
- 260 $a Ponchatoula : $b Existentialist Press, $c 1991.
- 300 $a xiv, 428 p. ...
- On t.p.: Coping with the absurd
- volume 2
- Ponchatoula * Existentialist Press * 1993
- This record may be used and treated as a multivolume record.
- E.g. Pieces form 2-volume set, with "tomo I" and "tomo II" on title
pages and "2a edición" on the
- t.p. versos.
- The only record for this title is for a one-volume publication,
without edition statement.
- This record is not a match. Even if the text is otherwise
unchanged, the 2nd edition is being
- explicitly presented as a 2-volume set in both volumes.
- Variations between a group of bibliographic volumes represented as being
issued together in a single volume and represented as issued as separate
physical volumes -- e.g., between "4 v. in 1" and "4 v." should be
evaluated on a case-by-case basis. It is safest to check with your trainer or
with the Library Associate before proceeding further.
- Variations in height between volumes of a multivolume set are not
significant for matching, even if they vary in height by more than 2 cm.
(Cf. Part II.E.5, section on editing size
in multivolume records.)
Go to top of this document
-
(Cf. Part II.E.6, section on editing series
in multivolume records.)
If there is no perfect match, but everything else that can be verified matches, the
presence or absence of a series does not prevent a match. Different volumes in
the same multivolume edition may appear in different series.
- E.g. 440 0 $a Music bibliographies ; $v 12, 15, 21
- 505 [includes v. 1, 3-4]
- You are cataloguing v. 2, which does not have the series "Music
bibliographies;" instead, it includes
- the series statement: Baroque musical
studies, 2. Otherwise, everything matches the bib record.
- This record may be a match.
Go to top of this document
HTML document last reviewed: 17 February 2000